C. Noel Henley, MD

Hand and Upper Extremity Specialist

  • About
  • For Patients
    • Deciding to Have Surgery
    • Nonsurgical Treatment
    • Living With One Hand
    • After Treatment
    • Instructions After Surgery
    • Make An Appointment
  • Disclaimer
  • Articles
  • What Patients are Saying
  • Appointments

Can Regenerative Medicine Re-grow a Finger?

September 13, 2010 by Dr. Henley

You may have seen a recent story on CNN about a patient whose finger grew back after the tip of the finger was amputated. This story is all over the internet and people are wondering (understandably) what all the fuss is about.


x-ray of a broken finger

x-ray of a broken finger

I’ll let you read the story and make up your own mind. As a hand surgeon, I have some strong feelings about this. Of course, I want nothing more than to sprinkle some regenerative powder on a patient’s finger and have a newly re-grown finger seven weeks later. This would eliminate a lot of surgery and uncomfortable bandage changes for many patients. However, it’s important that we look below the surface at this story.

What we can learn from this story

  • new treatments inspire hope
  • re-growing body parts is sensational and gets a lot of attention
  • being persistent as a patient can get you exactly what you want

Questions evidently never asked (that we know of) by the authors of the story

  • Where is the good evidence that this works? Have comparisons been done between the “letting it heal” method and using tissue regeneration powder?
  • How are these injuries treated now, without this new wonder drug?
  • Who treats these now? Why was a hand surgeon never interviewed?
  • Who benefits from this news story about a treatment that is not proven to work?
  • Where are the x-rays?
  • Why is her finger shorter if it “grew back”?
  • Why won’t it work for re-growing entire fingers?
  • Do people care about scientific rigor? This concept is never mentioned.
  • How is any treatment proven to work?

I don’t have the answers to the questions listed above. However, I know a balanced, thoughtful story when I see one published. Many of these questions should have been addressed.

Hand specialists have successfully treated hundreds of fingers like this (see Dr. Nelson’s page). “Sensational” results can and are achieved everyday by simply letting the body heal this on its own. This can be done for less than $50.

What happens when insurance companies find out the same results can be achieved for $50 instead of $1600? Also remember that her orthopaedic surgeon did a debridement of her finger. Was this in the office or in surgery? What was the cost of this part of her treatment?

I applaud this woman for getting what she wanted from her doctors and for educating herself and taking responsibility for getting the treatment she felt was right.

My point is not to dismiss regenerative medicine as snake oil. Rather, in our role as scientists, we have to look at this from all angles. This sometimes involves looking past hype and sensationalism.

Filed Under: hand surgery, news

EDUCATION PAGES

click on the links below to start learning:

  • arthritis: base of the thumb
  • arthritis: osteoarthritis
  • carpal tunnel syndrome
  • trigger finger
  • ganglion cysts
  • tennis elbow (epicondylitis)
  • wrist fractures
  • cubital tunnel syndrome
  • deQuervain's tendonitis
  • elbow fractures
  • olecranon bursitis
  • fingertip injuries
  • hand fractures

MAKE AN APPOINTMENT

Call our office today at 479-521-2752 to make an appointment with Dr. Henley

Featured Articles

Mallet Finger Injury

“my finger doesn’t work”“my finger is bent”“my finger won’t straighten”“my finger is drooped” These are several of the most common things I hear when patients come in with a mallet finger.  A mallet finger is the name for a ruptured (torn) tendon at the tip of the finger. A tendon rupture is where a tendon […]

Bad Thumb Arthritis – What Does It Look Like?

The video below shows a patient’s thumb moving back and forth. As you’ll see, most of the range of motion is at the MP (metacarpophalangeal) joint. This is abnormal – in a normal thumb, the majority of the motion is through the CMC (carpometacarpal joint, at the base of the thumb). When the CMC joint […]

Forearm Fractures In Kids – What Parents Need To Know

Bones in children are different from bones in adults. They break differently and they respond differently to injury. Some fractures occur both in adults and kids – some fractures occur only in children. Forearm fractures occur in both, with some important differences. This article will cover some of the basics of forearm fractures in kids. […]

Fingertip Ganglion Cysts – Mucous Cysts

The most common tumor in the finger is a ganglion cyst. A ganglion cyst is simply a fluid-filled sac. It can be visible from the outside or buried deep underneath the skin. Sometimes it causes symptoms like soreness and pain; other times patients have no idea it’s there. What is a mucous cyst? Ganglion cysts […]

Categories

  • anatomy
  • announcements
  • arthritis
  • bone health
  • carpal tunnel syndrome
  • common problems
  • current events
  • Famous Hands and Arms
  • FAQ
  • fractures
  • hand surgery
  • injections
  • media appearances
  • news
  • nonsurgical treatment
  • nutrition
  • philosophy of medicine
  • prevention
  • sports
  • surgery
  • tests
  • thumb
  • Uncategorized
  • video
  • wrist surgery

Copyright © 2023 · Dynamik-Gen on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in